The Rolling Stones: I'd Much Rather Be With The Boys (1965)

 |   |  1 min read

The Rolling Stones: I'd Much Rather Be With The Boys (1965)

Right at the end of the Rolling Stones doco Charlie is My Darling -- which captures extraordinary footage of a brief tour in Ireland in '65 with a stage invasion and general mayhem -- we see the Stones goofing off and playing a song that was a rarity.

This one.

And its rarity value is two-fold. First it was credited to Keith Richards and their manager Andrew Loog Oldham, and second that although they did a demo of it they never actually recorded the song but but gave it away to the much forgotten Toggery Five (who changed it substantially, to no avail, see clip below).

It is widely hailed however as one of the better originals which the Stones never intended for release and its lyrics are interesting. They are about valuing the gang more than the girls and, coming from Richards who was always fiercely loyal to the Stones, that makes them rather telling and prescient.

It's still not a lost classic, but in its nods to the Four Seasons, its Spector-lite production from Oldham and its Fifties referencing it does have a certain something.

MI0001394816Despite them not wanting it released, this came out anyway on the cobbled-together Metamorphosis album of '75 which their new manager Allen Klein thought might spark interest in cover versions.

And if you do your homework on the minor songs included on that album, that actually proved to be the case. Although none of the covers were major money-spinners as Klein hoped.

So Metamorphosis is still what it looks like, cobbled-together and done for the money.

I'd Much Rather Be With The Boys however is the one that got away.

For more one-offs, oddities or songs with an interesting back-story see From the Vaults

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   From the Vaults articles index

Lula Reed: I'll Drown in my Tears (1952)

Lula Reed: I'll Drown in my Tears (1952)

Although Ray Charles took a version of this soul classic to the top of the charts in 1956, this earlier version by Lula Reed (1921-2008) is the one to return to. A sassy and soulful r'n'b... > Read more

Bugotak: Kon Togethy (2006)

Bugotak: Kon Togethy (2006)

We could fill the bottomless black hole that is From the Vaults with just oddball versions of Beatles songs. (So far we have been restrained, just Laibach, cartoon character Elmer Fudd and the... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

ELVIS COSTELLO. LOOK NOW, CONSIDERED (2018): Songwriter Elvis Bacharach meet bandleader Burt McManus

ELVIS COSTELLO. LOOK NOW, CONSIDERED (2018): Songwriter Elvis Bacharach meet bandleader Burt McManus

Falling between his innovative mash-up/mix-up Wise Up Ghost with the hip-hop group The Roots (and don't call it self-sampling) and his latest Hey Clockface with its spoken word passages,... > Read more

GERRY MULLIGAN. IF YOU CAN'T BEAT 'EM, JOIN 'EM, CONSIDERED (1965): Through the smoke rings of his mind . . .

GERRY MULLIGAN. IF YOU CAN'T BEAT 'EM, JOIN 'EM, CONSIDERED (1965): Through the smoke rings of his mind . . .

When the much respected jazz writer Gene Lees asked the great baritone saxophonist Gerry Mulligan if he had any comments he'd like to make for the liner notes to this album Mulligan said,... > Read more