Bonnie Prince Billy: Lie Down in the Light (UKSpin)

 |   |  1 min read

Bonnie Prince Billy: Keep Eye on Other's Gain
Bonnie Prince Billy: Lie Down in the Light (UKSpin)

After establishing himself as the downbeat and somewhat gloomy singer-songwriter living in a half-lit corner of oldtime Americana, Will Oldham (aka Bonnie Prince Billy, Palace, Palace Brothers etc etc) sounds like he has changed his listening habits and maybe gone into a sun-soaked cornfield.
Some will find this disappointing and it does need to be said that this feels very lightweight in places, a few songs reveal his vocal limitations in this new (for him) genre, and he enters a world where he invites comparisons he can't win.
If this rather more bright outing has a close cousin it is Raising Sand by Robert Plant and Alison Krauss which tapped a similarly interesting vein and balanced optimism with its flipside -- and in that comparison Billy comes in a distant second place.
But here a jaunty clarinet comes in on For Every Field There's Is A Mole ("there's a time to sing these things and a time to have it sung"), he brings in Ashley Webber for some lovely harmonies, the crisp and open production allows the songs to breathe in a folksy way, and there's even something approaching a skip in his rhythmic step in many places.
And I'll be damned if Other's Gain ("keep your loved ones near") doesn't have a CS&Nash ring to it.
And from the man who is more used to singing "I see a darkness" now other phrases leap out everywhere which reiterate the changed mood: "It's all all right", "the friends and the family that love me", " I revel on in wonder at something so sweet and so long" . . .
If you'd found Billy a morose or testing artist in the past he's made an album that stretches in the sunshine, and although he hasn't turned into Donovan or Jack Johnson he keep you just enough on edge to know that while summer doesn't last you might as well enjoy it with family and loved ones while it is here.
Not his best album by a long shot, and bound to divide longtime listeners.

Share It

Your Comments

Martin - May 9, 2009

Bonnie boy has intrigued me after hearing most of his albums.His recentish Live album with the Scottish(i think) ensemble band was solid and quite consistent for him.I described his music to someone as a kind of depressed alt.country guy without really thinking.I agree with Graham he's patchy but when he puts his weird tilted stance to his best stuff he cooks.His latest doesn't draw you in as his stronger albums can.Hope he tours again soon.

post a comment

More from this section   Music at Elsewhere articles index

Jools Holland and His Rhythm and Blues Orchestra: Rockinghorse (Rhino)

Jools Holland and His Rhythm and Blues Orchestra: Rockinghorse (Rhino)

The celebrity-guest collections and R'N'B Orchestra discs from Jools Holland have often been tasty but a few not entirely successful. This sometimes breathless rush of boogie-woogie piano, big... > Read more

Various Artists: A Day in My Mind's Mind Vol 4 (Frenzy)

Various Artists: A Day in My Mind's Mind Vol 4 (Frenzy)

Although the recent initiative by recordedmusic.co.nz has brought some lost treasures (and some pretty ordinary music) back into public domain, this on-going compilation series pulls up some... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

YOU SAY IT'S YOUR BIRTHDAY (2024): And the band begins to play

YOU SAY IT'S YOUR BIRTHDAY (2024): And the band begins to play

Exactly 60 years ago to the day, the Beatles played in Auckland. It was my 13th birthday. I was a huge fan of course. I had their two albums Please Please Me and With the Beatles: the... > Read more

Katchafire: On the Road Again (EMI)

Katchafire: On the Road Again (EMI)

The title song/opener here is appropriate: for most of the past decade this hard-working band have been playing everywhere from small town bars and main centres around New Zealand to... > Read more