Matthew Sweet and Susanna Hoffs: Under the Covers Vol 2 (Shock)

 |   |  <1 min read

Matthew Sweet, Susanna Hoffs: Beware of Darkness (by George Harrison, Dhani Harrison on guitar
Matthew Sweet and Susanna Hoffs: Under the Covers Vol 2 (Shock)

The previous album by this hugely underrated power pop/rock singer songwriter and the former Bangle was a snapshot of their favourite Sixties songs (by the Beatles, Dylan, Neil Young, Stone Ponies, Who and so on) under the banner of Sid'n'Susie.

Here they undertake the diversity of the Seventies which means power pop (a rather mundane version of the Raspberries Go All the Way which lacks the urgency of the hormonal original), a reasonably faithful Fleetwood Mac's Second Hand News with Macman Lindsey Buckingham on guitars, an ache-less treatment of Clapton's pleading Bell Bottom Blues (with guitar by Gary Leisz), All the Young Dudes, a strong You're So Vain, Tom Petty's Here Comes My Girl . . . 

Any album that has Yes alongside Todd Rundgren's soul ballad Hello It's Me, Little Feat's Willin' and Maggie May (not to mention Lennon's angry Gimme Some Truth and Bread's soft-rock Everything I Own) was always going to be shapeless.

Much like the decade I guess.

Kinda fun and if you got the first one you'll probably want to collect the series, but I'd rather have another Matthew Sweet solo album any day. 

Share It

Your Comments

Mick "Trick" Gentilli - Sep 20, 2009

Is it me, or is Hoffs' harmony just a distraction on Cinnamon Girl? I admit to the fantasy "Snoggin' with the Walk Like An Egyptian Wild Child" daydream easily enough, but some covers are just best left alone. (OK, I just listened to a live jam version of Down By The River with Young and Phish, and I'm kind of in a snarky Don't Mess With My Dark Brooding Rock mood.)

Still.

Phildog - Oct 13, 2009

Cripes - it's gotta be said, it was clearly Matthew who ate all the pies - and Susanna's a total hottie!

Wicked site Graham!

post a comment

More from this section   Music at Elsewhere articles index

Various Artists: Country Soul Sisters (Soul Jazz/Southbound)

Various Artists: Country Soul Sisters (Soul Jazz/Southbound)

In a cover which bears no relevance to its contents and a 25-song decade-indifferent pastiche which roams freely between Jeannie C. Riley (the great Harper Valley PTA, of course), Lynn Anderson's... > Read more

Nina Simone: At Town Hall/The Amazing Nina Simone (Jackpot/Southbound)

Nina Simone: At Town Hall/The Amazing Nina Simone (Jackpot/Southbound)

Troublesome woman though she may have been -- angry, politically volatile, courageously self-obssessed -- there was never any denying her phenomenal, rare talent. Classically trained but with... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

WOMAD ARTIST 2015: Barbarito Torres of the Buena Vista Social Club

WOMAD ARTIST 2015: Barbarito Torres of the Buena Vista Social Club

Anyone who has tried to translate between different languages knows the difficulties: it's not just vocabulary but nuance, idioms, inflection and humour which can get lost somewhere along the... > Read more

THE BARGAIN BUY: Alice Cooper; The Very Best Of

THE BARGAIN BUY: Alice Cooper; The Very Best Of

Although this 14-song collection falls far short of its title -- classics like I'm Eighteen, Billion Dollar Babies, School's Out and No More Mr Nice Guy are all live versions from his '95 album... > Read more