Duffy: Endlessly (Universal)

 |   |  1 min read

Duffy: Girl
Duffy: Endlessly (Universal)

Poor Duffy. The preview tracks for her debut album Rockferry had everyone hailing her as one of the great new voices (even though she referred to classic pop and soul traditions) but when the album did arrive -- with some admittedly weaker tracks -- a section of the British press turned on her. They got in with the backlash even before the album was in stores.

But not so poor Duffy -- because Rockferry (justifiably) scooped up Brit awards (three including best album), sales in the many multiple millions and was nominated for three Grammys.

But it's poor Duffy time again because this album is not a patch on its predecesor, despite help from songwriter Albert Hammond Snr in the co-writing and co-production departments, and the Roots on board. But large swathes of this sound like she has abandoned that naturally powerful, soulful voice for some helium-inhaling and stabbing dance beats and synths which strip this of the human component.

Duffy at 26 seems to have regressed and is pitching herself as a late teen popette on material like the godwawful opener My Boy, the exceptionally irritating Well Well Well which sounds much longer than it 2.43 and the truly horrible Lovestruck.

When she gets into reflective mode (Don't Forsake Me with it soulful edge over strings and a distant "choral" part) it is much better (although even there she still isn't as interesting as similar songs on that debut). The title track is full of promise (although lyrically not up to much) but even here her vocals seem tight and, for want of a better phrase, adolescent.

Girl, towards the end -- if you get there -- is poppy and kinda cool.

You'd loved to have heard her do the interesting Child's Play a couple of years back. You suspect it would have benefited from a much more belting and resonant delivery free of the end-of-line quiver which sounds like a substitute for real emotion.

You don't look forward to "the difficult third album".

Poor Duffy?

Poor us. 

Share It

Your Comments

Leesa P - Dec 7, 2010

I concur!
Yikes that first single - please god make it stop! I find myself wanting to stick a pencil in my eye and roll it round for a bit just for some relief....

post a comment

More from this section   Music at Elsewhere articles index

Neil Watson: Studies in Tubular (neilwatson.co.nz/Southbound)

Neil Watson: Studies in Tubular (neilwatson.co.nz/Southbound)

Guitarist Neil Watson is a man with an impeccable track record of appearances on albums by Mel Parsons, the Finn Brothers, Caitlin Smith and more than a dozen others. He's a man who can sit... > Read more

Gomez: Five Men in a Hut (EMI)

Gomez: Five Men in a Hut (EMI)

No one reviewed this double disc when it came out late last year which is not surprising: although this British band picked up the coveted Mercury Award for their 1998 debut Bring It On they seem... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

EPs by Yasmin Brown

EPs by Yasmin Brown

With so many CDs commanding and demanding attention Elsewhere will run this occasional column by the informed and opinionated Yasmin Brown. She will scoop up some of those many EP releases, in... > Read more

Lindsay Beaver: Tough as Love (Alligator/Southbound)

Lindsay Beaver: Tough as Love (Alligator/Southbound)

For her Alligator debut singer/drummer Lindsay Beaver lives up to the label's remit of tough blues, and the album title. She's a real blues belter in the manner of Etta James (but in front of... > Read more