Giant Sand: Recounting the Ballads of The Thin Line Men (Fire/Southbound)

 |   |  <1 min read

Body of Water (2019)
Giant Sand: Recounting the Ballads of The Thin Line Men (Fire/Southbound)

Many artists talk about how they'd like to revisit and re-record parts of their catalogue, but few have done it as assiduously as Howe Gelb, the mainman of Giant Sand.

In the past decade he has gone back and re-hit, revisited and sometimes reinvented albums from their early catalogue.

For this one he goes back to their '86 album Ballad of Thin Line Man where the songs owed a bit to country-folk and a punk Neil Young. If you want to hear what the latter sounds like when applied to Dylan's All Along the Watchtower, the album is on Spotify here.

They also covered Johnny Thunders' classic You Can't Put Your Arms Around a Memory.

Now 33 1/3 years on from the album's original release Giant Sand take the songs (and Reptilian which was a bonus track on the 25thanniversary reissue) for another spin which frequently serves them up thicker and with more punch, and often more menacing courtesy of Gelb's darker and deeper voice (compare the versions of Body of Water, Who Am I and Memory).

They sidestep Watchtower this time but of the others Gelb's line in Tantamount is the key: “The song remains tantamount”.

Howe Gelb remains one of the more interesting artists who emerged in America's post-punk era who has constantly reinvented himself, even when seemingly going backwards as he has done recently.

This album is available on Spotify here but also on limited edition pink and purple coloured vinyl.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Music at Elsewhere articles index

Superturtle: Wait For It (Sarang Bang/digital outlets)

Superturtle: Wait For It (Sarang Bang/digital outlets)

There's always something appealingly quirky and almost quaint about Auckland's Superturtle helmed by Darren McShane. As with their previous albums, Wait For It comes on vinyl with a striking... > Read more

Gomez: Five Men in a Hut (EMI)

Gomez: Five Men in a Hut (EMI)

No one reviewed this double disc when it came out late last year which is not surprising: although this British band picked up the coveted Mercury Award for their 1998 debut Bring It On they seem... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

PAUL McCARTNEY: AMOEBA GIG, CONSIDERED (2007/2019): That was him standing there

PAUL McCARTNEY: AMOEBA GIG, CONSIDERED (2007/2019): That was him standing there

In the decade after he disbanded Wings at the end of the Seventies, Paul McCartney's recording career on albums offered diminishing returns outside of a string of mostly vacuous chart hits. It... > Read more

WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT . . . LIBBY HOLMAN: Sex, scandal, shooting and suicide

WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT . . . LIBBY HOLMAN: Sex, scandal, shooting and suicide

When they found singer Libby Holman dead in her Rolls Royce of carbon monoxide poisoning in 1971, her suicide brought an end to a life marked by scandal, sexual promiscuity, one dead husband and a... > Read more