THE UNKINDEST CUT: The author, the interview, the sub-editor and me

 |   |  2 min read

THE UNKINDEST CUT: The author, the interview, the sub-editor and me

When the India-born, Oxford and Stanford-educated author Vikram Seth came to New Zealand in 1988 he was still some years away from his acclaimed and enormous novel A Suitable Boy.

He was on a book tour-cum-holiday and being taken around by the PR woman for his publisher to talk about his two books so far: From Heaven Lake; Travels Through Sinkiang and Tibet, and a poetry novel The Golden Gate, a brilliantly satirical piece about yuppies in San Francisco written in sonnet form.

When his name was raised at a Herald writers' meeting as a possible interview subject people just looked blankly, but I said I'd read both books.

And I had.

Suddenly the long-haired guy who'd only been there a few months and wrote about rock music – and was weird enough to genuinely like jazz – had another hidden dimension.

Reid read.

And so I met with the charming Vikram Seth in a small featureless room at the Herald and we started to chat.

I was the last person he'd be seeing on his tour and with exasperation but generosity he said no one who had interviewed him had actually read a single word he'd written.

When I said I'd read both books he clapped his hands in delight and the allotted 15 minutes turned into almost an hour before he was beckoned away by his minder.

vikIt had been an excellent interview, more a conversation really, and I went back to my desk aglow.

But when I rewound the tape and listened back – I didn't do shorthand then, still don't – not a word had been captured.

I was distraught but wise Colin Hogg, my entertainment editor, said to just go to a quiet place and see what I could reconstruct.

So I did: I looked at my questions and – because he spoke with such a distinctive accent, vaguely American with Indian inflections – I could recall huge swathes of what he said.

I knew I had my story and if the words weren't always exactly what he said – and I shifted some into reported speech – they were certainly as close as dammit.

He would be fairly represented. 

I wrote up my substantial interview and passed it over to a sub-editor called Dennis so it could appear as a feature the following day.

Later however he passed my desk and with a dismissive aside said some ads had come in and he'd had to cut my piece.

My heart sank, I knew what that could mean.

When I left the Herald I thanked the subs because, as I pointed out, they could save a writer from looking foolish or ending up in court.

I didn't say that on one occasion a sub said they'd had to cut a piece and I caught it before it went to the compositors.

“But, you've cut off the punchline,” I wailed.

“Then you shouldn't have put it at the end,” she said.

I salvaged that one, but the morning after my Vikram Seth interview I picked up the paper.

My published interview was about a quarter of what I had presented.

Dennis had cut out every single “quote”.

.

These entries are of little consequence to anyone other than me Graham Reid, the author of this site, and maybe my family, researchers and those with too much time on their hands.

Enjoy these random oddities at Personal Elsewhere.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Personal Elsewhere articles index

SUCH DREAMS AS COME: At night, then the light

SUCH DREAMS AS COME: At night, then the light

The recurring dreams are different – but very detailed. Yet there's something which binds them in my subconscious. In the first and most common I am in a strange city, some of which I... > Read more

SHALL WE DANCE?: You know how times fade away

SHALL WE DANCE?: You know how times fade away

It wasn't until I met Miss Havisham on the pages of Great Expectations that I understood what a spinster was. Which is strange because growing up there were two unmarried, elderly women –... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE QUESTIONNAIRE: Ryan Munroe from Band of Horses

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE QUESTIONNAIRE: Ryan Munroe from Band of Horses

Band of Horses are an American group which a select but growing audience in New Zealand has embraced, largely on the strength of them touring here early (earlyish) in their career . . . and then... > Read more

Geraldo Pino: Heavy Heavy Heavy (RetroAfrica/Southbound)

Geraldo Pino: Heavy Heavy Heavy (RetroAfrica/Southbound)

Some weeks ago I posted a track by the late and very great Fela Anikulapo Kuti from Nigeria who put James Brown funk, Black Power politics and African rhythms into the blender and created Afrobeat.... > Read more